Mozi’s Argumentation and Practical Spirit of “JianAi”

Author:Szu-Hsuan Hung

Abstract / PDF Download

Mozi’s theory of Jian Ai was reconstructed under the form of western philosophy by many scholars. However, I discover that Mozi used different kinds  of  argumentations  to  justify  Jian  Ai  concerning  different  audience.When  facing  the  opponent,  Mozi  justified  Jian  Ai  by  refuting  arguments.And  he  encouraged  supporter’s  faith  through  publicizing  the  principle  of reciprocity. However, the practical spirit of Jian Ai is not elucidated by the principle of refutation and reciprocity. This research tries to figure out the practical spirit of Jian Ai from Mozi. My conclusion is that to practice Jian Ai is the value itself. Regardless of any additional benefit, action of Jian Ai is morality.  Moral  practice  is  originated  from  Jian  Ai.  Although  the  realisticbenefit is limited by causality the practical spirit of Jian Ai is intact.

Keywords: benefit (li)、inclusive love (Jian Ai)、righteousness (yi)、will of Heaven (tain zhi )